
A Rope Over An Abyss
A friend commented regarding the post of yesterday, that my anger was showing, a turbulence roiling the waters of mind and expression. Nevertheless I continue because what follows in the Nietzschean tale is important that we consider.
Our leading character in this tale is Zarathustra, who by chance happens upon a gathering of townspeople in the marketplace square. They are there to be entertained by a high-wire walker, (the rope dancer) who is to traverse the square upon a rope stretched high overhead of the observers. Who is not eager to see a life and death performance? The crowd waits breathlessly. Zarathustra having something to say seizes the interlude before the main event to deliver his message to the crowd.
~*~
Perhaps you’ve been at a concert, the opening act is ending, everyone is anxious to experience the main event. In the crowd someone shouts out for the main act to begin, – the crowd laughs.
The waiting tightrope performer hearing the commotion begins his crossing, high above the crowd, above the cobblestones below.
Zarathustra though, is not finished, there’s one more point to convey, and he continues to speak.
“You my friend(s) are that rope stretched across an abyss,” – speaking loud enough for everyone to hear. I would wager the laughter becomes silence, all eyes are on the tightrope walker, tensely suspended above their heads while they hear these words:
When Zarathustra had thus spoken,
one of the people called out:
“We’ve heard enough of the tightrope walker; now let’s see him also!”
And all the people laughed at Zarathustra.
But the tightrope walker,
who thought the words were for him,
began his performance.
Zarathustra, however,
looked at the people and wondered.
Then he spoke thus:
Man is a rope stretched between animal and Overman
— a rope over an abyss.
A dangerous crossing, a dangerous on-the-way, a dangerous looking back,
a dangerous trembling and halting.
What is great in man is that he is a bridge and not a goal:
what can be loved in man is that he is an over-going and a down-going.
I love those who know not how to live
except as down-goers,
for they are the over-goers.
I love the great despisers,
because they are the great adorers,
and arrows of longing for the other shore.
I love those who do not
first seek a reason beyond the stars
for going down and being sacrifices,
but sacrifice themselves to the earth,
that the earth of the Overman may someday arrive.
I love him who lives in order to know,
and seeks to know in order that
the Overman may someday live.
Thus he seeks his own down-going.
I love him who works and invents,
that he may build a house for the Overman,
and prepare for him earth, animal, and plant:
for thus he seeks his own down-going.
Thus Spake Zarathustra, by Friedrich Nietzsche, Trans. by Thomas Common, aphorism 3
If the words of Zarathustra frighten you, as well as invite you, that is precisely how they effect me too. These words challenge, are a provocation to be, to become more, much more than I or anyone else has imagined. I am encouraged to dispense with limiting and negative expectations that I learned from others. Why does it matter? The future actually depends upon my openness today to the lessons my circumstances have to teach. The suggestion is made that we cannot envision the potential for greatness that will be slowly fulfilled generation by generation.
That humility, mindfulness, and self-possession are their own justification, are in themselves warranted.
The earth and every living thing, the future co-depends upon my practice.
Courage! If you are just beginning to get the idea. This is heavy. It takes a while.
4 thoughts on “A Rope Over An Abyss”
Years ago, while working for the Public Works Center at Great Lakes Naval Training Center, I came to know a fellow in another department. Mike was a nice enough guy, soft spoken but seemed to think deeply about things. We would converse about those things from time to time, didn’t always agree but that didn’t matter, I’m sure he felt the same about me, it was the friendship that was important. Well, that was years and years ago and I had lost track of him until a week ago, from Kenosha came the news:
https://inmate.kenoshajs.org/NewWorld.InmateInquiry/kenosha/Inmate/Detail/-851536
Seems he decided to take to vandalism, at 71 years of age. I assume it was over politics. I felt sorry for him, they had video of him doing it. Yet there he was in a photo scratching the paint on a Tesla. Did I feel anger towards him, no, all I could feel was his humiliation at being caught and think of the time he would now spend in jail, away from family. The dumb bastard, I thought, at a time of his life when he should be relaxing and having fun with his wife and grandchildren. I’m sure he will miss that along with suffer the humiliation over doing something like that. Just what in the hell made it so important to him to resort to vandalism and damaging the vehicle of someone he didn’t even know?
What has happened to the Democrats? I could say the ‘left’ but nothing has changed with them, they are the same old sour, vengeful folks.
I say Democrats because they once prided themselves on producing elected officials who were suave, sophisticated and smart: leaders like Adlai Stevenson, John and Robert Kennedy, Bill Clinton, Bill Bradley, Joe Lieberman and Barack Obama.
I now get the feeling that the progressives who run the Democratic Party today would have no interest resurrecting any of those political figures, aside from Obama. Even Senator Chuck Schumer has gotten more guttural and indelicate. Oh my God, and now they have turned on him. Senators Bernie Sanders, Elizabeth Warren and Representative Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez have given the Party a more piercing sound and rough-edged look. “FUCK” is now the new cry from their poison ivORy tower.
So, what’s the point, be careful is all I can say. Maybe your turn to almost violence is normal but it will lead to calamity as has befallen my friend Mike. Be sure it’s worth doing and don’t be taken in by one of your Group who touts violence to often.
I don’t want to feel sorry for you if you do something stupid.
Gary
Gary, it is a pleasure to hear from you. I miss your storytelling skill of which this is a good example.
The meaning of an event is always, without exception in the eye of the beholder.
You label the damage to a Tesla, a product of Elon Musk company as vandalism. The authorities certainly would agree with you and your friend will surely pay a fine and perhaps spend some time in jail.
Others will understand the action as one of defiance, a statement of resistance against DOGE, of which Musk is the driver, a cartoon-like chainsaw wielding promoter… Under Musk’s direction thousands have been laid off and the meat-axe approach to downsizing government rolls on. What you view as shameful, a disgrace others would view as a courageous resistance to a heartless cruel tyranny, families arbitrarily rendered jobless. And Musk as its agent.
Perhaps you’ve changed your mind about the event of December 16th, 1773 – now standing with the British king?
Well Jerry, I guess I’ll have to go out and start scratching up VWs because Hitler created them. Gee, I hope that sounds stupid to you, it does me.
How in the heck is scratching someone’s personal car, many who probably bought it because they believed they were protecting the environment, to be consider an act of good?
‘Eye of the beholder’, you say? These acts are in the eye of the LAW, no question the it’s an illegal act and it does not matter what excuse/reason you put forward. My Grand daughter and her husband both have Teslas, both are on the left and now have to live in fear of their own kind damaging their cars. (But the left is known to eat its own) I think you are leaning a bit too far over the abyss.
As for the tea party, those who took part knew they could be caught and hanged by the king, they won, thank God, and we grew a bit freer. For heaven’s sake, fight Musk if you must, but leave private people out of it. If you don’t, I think you are cowards. Those who tossed over board the tea stood up and were seen, they were brave and took the risk for freedom. They didn’t cower behind the darkness and between parked cars with a little key to cause harm to innocents.
You are entering into anarchy. Good Luck
I hear you. That nothing matters except your way of thinking. Should I excuse you because you are unable to entertain hypothesis, unless they support only what these acts mean to you? Ought I give you a pass because you cannot help but think the way you do? I think that you ought to stretch to acknowledge a viewpoint with which you disagree. The legal status of these acts are not in question here. But you insist upon making that the only issue worth discussing.
Again I mention the Boston Tea Party event. Individuals that ignite a Tesla are taking commensurate risk by the Trump administration’s standard of “justice.” There is and will be less or no due process with Trump in office. And how are you going to leave private people out of a conflict upon which the future course of society depends? You know as well as I that is absurd, impossible to do.
This anarchy has been long coming. For my entire adult lifetime Republicans using Fox as a bullhorn have talked smack. Now the mask is off, “might makes right” in the figure of the insurrectionist now occupying the White House, as well as his protege, Elon Musk.